Sarah Hyland and Sadie Dickerson Step Into JUST IN TIME on Broadway
Broadway is about to welcome two powerhouse talents to its latest smash hit musical, JUST IN TIME. Beginning September 16, Sadie Dickerson will make her Broadway debut as Sandra Dee, followed by Sarah Hyland stepping into the role of Connie Francis on October 8.
Starring alongside Tony Award winner Jonathan Groff as Bobby Darin, this star-studded production is quickly becoming one of the most talked-about shows in New York City theater circles. For audiences in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and even The Hamptons, this is shaping up to be a must-see event of the season. With tickets already in high demand, the arrival of these two celebrated performers adds even more excitement to an already sold-out run.
Broadway’s Rising Star: Sadie Dickerson Takes the Stage
On September 16, Sadie Dickerson will step into the role of Sandra Dee, taking over from Erika Henningsen, who plays her final performance on September 14.
Dickerson, who hails from Austin, Texas, brings a fresh voice to Broadway. A graduate of Missouri State University with a BFA in Musical Theatre and a Certificate in Acting for the Camera, she has already made a mark Off-Broadway with her role in Vladimir at Manhattan Theatre Club.
“Sadie Dickerson is thrilled to be making her Broadway debut”
Her casting signals a new chapter for JUST IN TIME, giving audiences the chance to see an up-and-coming performer take on one of the most iconic figures of the 1960s.
Sarah Hyland Returns to Broadway in a Role Made for Her
Just weeks later, on October 8, Sarah Hyland will take over the role of Connie Francis from Gracie Lawrence. For Hyland, this marks a triumphant return to the Broadway stage after her acclaimed turn as Daisy in The Great Gatsby earlier this year.
Hyland, best known for her role as Haley Dunphy on the award-winning series Modern Family, has been performing since childhood. She first appeared on Broadway at 16 in Grey Gardens and has since built a career that spans film, television, and theater.
Her resume includes everything from starring in the remake of Dirty Dancing to producing and hosting the family competition special Play-Doh Squished. On the film side, Hyland has worked on projects like The Wedding Year and My Fake Boyfriend, while also lending her voice to the hit podcast Bone, Marry, Bury.
Hyland’s dual talents as a performer and entrepreneur make her a perfect fit for the role of Connie Francis.
“Sarah Hyland is a true triple threat,”
The production notes emphasize underscoring her ability to bring depth and authenticity to one of America’s most beloved entertainers.
Jonathan Groff Anchors the Musical as Bobby Darin
At the heart of JUST IN TIME is Jonathan Groff’s magnetic performance as Bobby Darin. Known for his work in Hamilton and Merrily We Roll Along, Groff brings both charisma and vulnerability to the role of the legendary singer.
The musical, directed by Tony Award winner Alex Timbers, invites audiences into an intimate nightclub setting where a live on-stage band plays Darin’s biggest hits, including Beyond the Sea, Splish Splash, Dream Lover, and Mack the Knife.
With its immersive staging and emotionally charged storytelling, the show has become the talk of the theater world since its opening on April 26, 2025.
Behind the Scenes of a Broadway Sensation
The creative team behind JUST IN TIME reads like a who’s who of Broadway talent.
-
Book by Tony Award winner Warren Leight (Side Man) and Isaac Oliver (The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel)
-
Music supervision by Tony nominee Andrew Resnick (Parade)
-
Orchestrations by Andrew Resnick and Michael Thurber
-
Choreography by Shannon Lewis (Saturday Night Live, Fosse)
-
Scenic design by Derek McLane (Death Becomes Her)
-
Costume design by Catherine Zuber (Moulin Rouge!)
This collaboration has resulted in a production that is both visually stunning and musically unforgettable.
New York’s Cultural Scene
For audiences in neighborhoods like the Upper East Side, Tribeca, and Greenwich Village, JUST IN TIME offers more than just an evening of entertainment. It’s a reminder of Broadway’s resilience and creativity, showcasing new talent like Dickerson alongside established stars like Hyland and Groff.
With exclusive nightclub-style seating available, theatergoers can immerse themselves in an experience that feels both glamorous and deeply personal.
Tickets start at $99 and are available at the Circle in the Square Theatre box office or JustInTimeBroadway.com. Given the show’s critical acclaim and high demand, early booking is strongly recommended.
Fresh energy for JUST IN TIME
As the show continues its run through January 11, 2026, the addition of Dickerson and Hyland promises to bring fresh energy to the production. Whether you’re a lifelong fan of Bobby Darin or simply looking for a standout night of live performance, this is a musical that delivers on every level.
